How to buy a second home and rent the first, according to financial planners and tax experts

How to buy a second home and rent the first, according to financial planners and tax experts

by Liz Knueven
November 25, 2020

How to buy a second home and rent the first, according to financial planners and tax experts

How to buy a second home and rent the first, according to financial planners and tax experts

by Liz Knueven
November 25, 2020


If you're ready to move and you want to start earning rental income, you might be considering buying a second home and renting out your first.

Renting out a home on a full-time or part-time basis can be an excellent way to make some extra cash. But it's also likely to bring its own set of expenses. 

If you're considering buying a second home and renting out the first, there's a lot to consider before making your second home purchase and listing your home for rent. 

Make sure it's the right move for your overall financial plan

Any second home you buy should fit in with your other financial goals, not replace them.

Financial planner Brent Weiss suggests prioritizing your financial goals to see where a second home would fit. From saving for retirement to sending your kids to college, a second home shouldn't stand in the way of your other goals. 

While the extra rental income might be nice, it's also worth considering the expenses. "A lot of people don't realize all of the expenses that will come with it, and how it's actually going to impact their cash flow," Weiss says. "The down payment, the closing costs, all of these things are going to impact the cash they have on hand."

You'll need to consider saving more for home repairs, and either saving extra in your current home repair fund or starting a second one for your new home.

Understand all the tax implications in advance

If you're planning to make rental income on one of your properties, there will be quite a few things that will change on your taxes.

When renting out a home, most people are able to deduct expenses in addition to mortgage interest and property taxes up to $10,000 per year, tax expert and CPA Lisa Greene-Lewis said. Your second home's bills, maintenance costs, and even improvement costs can become deductible expenses. However, you'll have to pay income tax on the money your second home brings in. 

Talking with a tax expert can help you get a better idea of what exactly to expect, and help you avoid any future surprises on your taxes.

Search for a home within your budget, and don't overspend

Weiss says that it's all too common for people to fall in love with second homes out of their price range, only to overspend on their new property.

"People go and find their dream home. It is inevitably above the budget. The house is more expensive, so their closing costs are higher, the down payment is larger, and your monthly mortgage is larger than you want it to be," he says. That's often when a second home starts to impact other financial goals.

Look for something that you could afford even if you didn't make any rental income on your other home, financial planner Andrew Rosen previously told Business Insider. Weiss agrees. "Do you have the money available to cover a couple extra months of the mortgage? What does that mean for the rest of your [financial] plan?"

Overspending on your home could greatly impact other parts of your financial plan, and that could be a problem for your other long-term goals. 

Think about your long-term plans for your first home

Chances are, the second home you're looking to move into is a long-term investment. But what are your long-term plans for the first home? It's a good idea to consider this before making your next purchase. 

If you eventually plan to sell the first home, it's worth considering the tax implications in advance. If you sell a home that's not your primary residence, you could owe capital gains tax. That could mean paying as much as 20% of the profit in taxes. 

However, that can be avoided by selling the home when you've lived there for two of the last five years, or by moving back in. It never hurts to plan ahead, and while renting it out might be the right move for now, it's worth considering the possibilities for the future.

This article was written by Liz Knueven from Business Insider and was legally licensed through the Industry Dive publisher network. Please direct all licensing questions to

Are you looking to buy a second house? Before you start going on showings, contact the loan officers at Wintrust Mortgage to discuss your options.


Stay Connected